Pizza Time

Discover Pizza Time in St. Augustine, FL, offering delicious NY-style pizza, garlic knots, lasagna pizza, and more. Enjoy authentic flavors, friendly service, and a cozy atmosphere at 124 St. George St. Call +1 904-819-0133 today!

Welcome to Pizza Time

Experience the finest dining

Pizza Time
Pizza Time
Pizza Time
Pizza Time

Pizza Time really captures the essence of New York-style pizza right in the heart of St. Augustine. Located at 124 St George St, this cozy spot is a local favorite for those who crave quality pizza. The menu tempts with options from classic cheese slices to unique offerings like burrata and lasagna pizzas. Each dish celebrates bold flavors, and that aromatic garlic fill ushers you in. Active locals and visitors alike line up, especially on Saturdays, to indulge in the beloved garlic knots that come piping hot.

Cash only, it keeps the process swift and straightforward, ensuring quicker turnovers for hungry guests. Whether it's a quick bite while exploring historic St. Augustine or a relaxed group outing, Pizza Time guarantees satisfaction with every slice.

Pizza Time boasts a variety of features that enhance the dining experience. The centerpiece is the signature New York-style pizza, each slice layered with delicious toppings that define comfort food. Regulars rave about the gelato, a refreshing treat that complements the savory dishes. Each pizza comes out of the oven with an enticing crust, crisp on the outside yet soft inside. Expect long lines during peak times, particularly on Saturdays around 4 PM.

Early birds can take advantage of the best times to visit, like late mornings. This casual eatery brings a vibrant community spirit where friends gather over shared plates. Parking can be a challenge when the café buzzes, but the food is worth the wait.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

124 St George St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, United States

Phone

+1 904-819-0133

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Pizza Time
Pizza Time
Pizza Time
Pizza Time

Pizza Time stands as a testament to true passion for pizza. Founded on the belief that quality ingredients lead to remarkable flavors, it taps into a simple mission: serve excellent food without pretension. The menu is intentionally crafted, targeting pizza lovers of all backgrounds. Customization is an essential element here, and patrons enjoy choosing toppings that range from classic pepperoni to fresh ingredients like spinach and artichokes. Families love the array of options, such as grandma pizza which harks back to traditional recipes and brings nostalgia.

Vegetarian options abound too, appealing to diverse dietary needs. On the culinary horizon, Pizza Time holds a solid reputation not just for pizza but also for the delightful garlic knots and gelato that often steal the spotlight.

Every bite at Pizza Time immerses visitors in a rich tapestry of flavors. Whether dining solo or with a group, the atmosphere resonates with laughter and chatter, reflecting a community that prides itself on togetherness. The decor embraces a casual, inviting vibe, making it an accessible eatery for all.

Visitors often share tables, fostering a sense of connection. Notably, the restaurant's commitment to quality runs deep. It sources local ingredients where possible, ensuring freshness with each dish served. Special events or promotions occasionally enhance the experience, keeping locals curious and engaged. Every Saturday, patients risk missing out at 4 PM, but the payoff is undeniable. A visit here becomes not just about dinner; it turns into a memory, often accompanied by stories shared with friends.

Pizza Time keeps St.

Augustine’s pizza culture rich and vibrant. It prides itself on adapting the New York-style approach while maintaining a heartfelt connection to the local community. Weekend nights filled with laughter and flavorful bites turn into cherished experiences that draw residents back, creating a loyal following.

Pizza Time

Pizza Time presents a charming facade that feels welcoming at first glance. Bright signage beckons passersby with mouth-watering promises, often enhanced by scents wafting from the kitchen. Outside, seating options allow for a casual dining experience amidst the scenic beauty of St. Augustine. Locals enjoy people-watching while savoring their favorite slices on the patio. The vibrant atmosphere captures the lively spirit of the community, drawing in both tourists exploring historic streets and neighborhood regulars. Many diners take a moment to soak in the sunshine before diving into their delicious orders.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday10 AM-11 PM
  • Monday10 AM-10:30 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-10:30 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-10:30 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-10:30 PM
  • Friday10 AM-11 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-11 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

The best pizza in not only Florida, but the entire US! Place is exceptionally well run and cash only (atms are located in the store fortunately). Line can be long at high traffic times but well worth the wait. Portions are quite large and everything on the menu is a must try (especially the Caesar salad and garlic knots). We were blown away with how great it was we had to come back a second time!

W
Wyatt W.

Great pizza! Perfect crust. Savory cheese. Just the right sauce to cheese to crust ratio. They know pizza. This place is only cash so be prepared. They have an ATM if you forget. It's right on the strip. They stay open while others close at night. It can get pretty crowded but it's worth the wait. Expect to pay tourist prices for slices. We've come here before. They seriously have the best rustica pizza I've ever had (roasted vegetables). I think it has at least 7 different veggies. I stopped counting. Plenty of seating for the whole family too.

E
E. B.

My Italian friend and I, also an Italian, took one look at the shop window and were instantly drawn in by the New York cut of Caprese Pizza. We only got one piece, but our minds went through the whole menu. It was five star quality food and we would love to go try it again

M
M-L O.

Its one of my top pizzas around and one of my wife and i places to eat in St. Augustine. It's an only cash pizza place, make sure you have it if not, there is an atm right there. It's not a super big pizza shop, but it has some good seating. Most of the time there is a line out the door. The window is a beautiful thing to look at, you see all the pizza making and all of the types of pizza flavors they have. The slices are pretty large each one is about $9-$10 a slice, and let me tell you its completely worth it. Our favorite is the Genova, which is a white pizza with chicken, ricotta, and herbs. Also the chicken parm is delicious and the garlic knots are to die for; they are hot, soft, and definitely have garlic. Drinks are separate. They have calzones, salads, potato balls and large pizza orders. Its a good place to have lunch or a quick slice. It is definitely filling but worth it, it requires a nap after back at the hotel lol.

J
J. B.

Classic NYC pizza spot. The line is long for dinner, but we found it was worth it. (Moves quickly) Choose your pizza, pay, sit, and enjoy. No frills- great tasting pizza, clean tables, nice staff, kinda pricey, but to be expected. Decorated nicely for Christmas! *Cash only- ATM on site.*

N
Nancy D.

I like pizza and this was probably the best pepperoni slice of pizza I've ever had! No wait today! Friendly staff and quick service. A slice with a cold beer and indoor seating. A great selection of pizza and garlic rolls.

M
Matt S.