Pizza Time Menu (Update 2026)

Pizza Time offers an enticing menu filled with the flavors of New York. You can savor pizza by the slice, perfect for those in a hurry or just looking to sample various toppings.

Don't miss the garlic knots; these soft, buttery delights are a signature starter. The lasagna pizza and burrata pizza are crowd favorites, showcasing creative twists on traditional recipes. For a delightful dessert, try the gelato, available in fun flavors like strawberry, mango, and piña colada. Just remember, this place only accepts cash, making it essential to plan accordingly before your visit.

Featured Dishes

Margarita Pizza and Lasagne Pizza
Margarita Pizza and Lasagne Pizza
Olives
Olives
Beer
Beer
Calzone
Calzone
Wine
Wine
Cannoli
Cannoli
Marinara Sauce
Marinara Sauce
Brooklyn Pizza
Brooklyn Pizza
Waters
Waters
Meat Pizza
Meat Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Focaccia
Focaccia
Great Soda Selection
Great Soda Selection
Specialty Pizzas
Specialty Pizzas
Rustica
Rustica
Burrata Caprese Pizza
Burrata Caprese Pizza
Pizza Time Menu image 1
Pizza Time Menu image 2
Pizza Time Menu image 3
Pizza Time Menu image 4
Pizza Time

Pizza Time Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Pizza Time, you experience a lively and warm atmosphere filled with the tantalizing aroma of fresh pizza. The charming decor reflects the New York vibe, making it a cozy spot to enjoy a meal with friends or family.

Long lines often greet diners as they enter, a testament to the quality and popularity of their offerings. Inside, the casual dining area provides a welcoming space to relax and indulge in freshly made slices, gelato, and more. Enjoy your meal surrounded by locals sharing stories, creating a genuine sense of community.

Pizza Time

About Pizza Time Food and Specialties

Pizza Time excels in providing authentic NY-style pizza, drawing locals and tourists alike to its charming St. Augustine location. Each pizza is crafted with care, ensuring fresh ingredients and a delicious crust that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Specialties like grandma pizza and lasagna pizza add an innovative flair to the menu, while their selection of gelato offers a sweet treat to cool down on warm days. For those seeking variety, the restaurant provides flavorful potato balls, bringing a bit of comfort food into the mix. This inviting eatery promises satisfying meals that cater to every craving.

Pizza Time

Pizza Time commits to delivering the best in casual dining. The focus remains on crafting mouth-watering pizzas that draw repeat visitors. Their specialty lies in creating unique flavor profiles that stand out in a crowded market. The burrata and lasagna pizzas showcase innovative combinations that offer a twist on classic favorites. This restaurant envisions a space where everyone feels welcome, fostering connections through shared meals. Pizza Time constantly evolves, bringing fresh ideas while remaining anchored in quality. It aims to keep the community engaged, with plans to introduce seasonal flavors that highlight local ingredients. Such initiatives reflect a commitment not just to flavor but to the relationship with St. Augustine.